Series 8 Episode 9: FCA FRAME: reshaping reporting for Asset and Wealth Management

In this episode, PwC directors Andrew Strange and Tom Bramhill join to discuss the FCA’s proposed Fund Reporting for Asset Management Entities (FRAME) and what it means for Asset and Wealth Management firms. They explore the practical data and reporting challenges, the interaction with wider UK and European regulation, and how firms can prepare for an increasingly data-led approach to supervision while identifying opportunities beyond compliance.

Listen on: Apple Podcasts  Spotify

Transcript

Dan Perks: Hi everyone and welcome to Risk and Regulation Rundown, the podcast where we explore the latest issues shaping financial services risk and regulation. I’m your guest host, Dan Perks, and in today’s episode we’re discussing regulatory developments in the Asset and Wealth Management industry, with particular focus on the FCA’s current FRAME consultation. We’ll dive into what this means for firms, the drivers behind it and what firms should be thinking about doing right now.

I’m pleased to be joined by two brilliant guests. Firstly, Andrew Strange, a Director specialising in Asset and Wealth Management regulation from PwC’s Financial Services Regulatory Insights team, and Tom Bramhill a Director in PwC’s Asset and Wealth Management Risk and Regulatory Consulting practice. Both, thanks so much for joining me today.

Andrew Strange: Hi Dan.

Tom Bramhill: Hi Dan.

Dan: Andrew, as I mentioned, the FCA is currently consulting on FRAME. Can you start by explaining to our listeners what FRAME is? What the FCA is proposing here, and what problems the FCA is really trying to solve by doing this?

Andrew: I certainly can Dan, although I'm sure most of the listeners will have read it already because it's jolly exciting. This is one of the latest consultations that's come out of the FCA this autumn, it came out this summer; to be consulted on over the course of the autumn and it closed for comments around the end of October. Broadly what it is, is a replacement for a whole range of reporting in the funds space at the moment. Badged as simplification, but not necessarily, and perhaps we'll pick up on that later on. At a broad level, some context for this, we've got the regulator having talked for a couple of years now about wanting to become more data led. They're focused on that growth agenda, quite rightly, and they want to create a simpler and more proportionate regulatory framework, including on the reporting that we have in the fund’s world. What this is, however, is pretty much a rewriting of all of the reporting that goes on for funds. It extends to a wider population of entities. And it has quite different kind of data, data points, values and so on that fit within it as well, so It's quite a fundamental change and it's quite different. As I say, it applies to all funds and what we're looking at is a tiered set of features and data reporting requirements to make it proportionate. At the moment, or under consultation is around a now value of £500m. But obviously that doesn't align with some of the proposals we've seen elsewhere and things like the AFM proposals, so that may change, you never know. It also tries to be more accurate. The regulator wants to be data led. So, it's thinking about what are the hot issues that we'd like more data on? So, things like liquidity, things like private markets. It really becomes more targeted and tailored in terms of larger fund sizes, funds with particular exposures, particular approaches, but it fundamentally therefore makes it quite different from some of the slightly more transactional template-based reporting we've seen already. It also is running at quite a pace. The regulator, as I said, was consulting over the autumn and it closed at the end of October. They’re already talking to some firms about prototype forms to test how this kind of works. And we're expecting final rules in the first half of 2027. Implementation maybe 2028, 2029 and it's not yet clear in terms of implementation periods and transitional periods and so on. And certainly, there's been some push back from industry around the broader range of regulatory issues that they're facing with similar kind of implementation dates. But the prototyping of the form is something that's happening at the moment. Final rules are expected in the first half of next year.

Dan: A really useful explanation there. Thank you for that. And it's not just the current FRAME consultation either, which firms should be aware of. There’re other regulatory developments taking place and the FRAME consultation is part of that wider ecosystem. Tom, can you share a bit more insight on those other elements within the regulatory sphere that firms should be aware of?

Tom: Yes, absolutely. Thanks Dan. And you're absolutely spot on. The FCA has been extremely busy over the last few months, maybe the last year or so, making rules. And what we've got here with the FRAME proposals is something which ties quite explicitly to a couple of other pieces of regulation. We've already had a liquidity policy statement for liquidity and funds. We've also got ongoing a consultation on the UK's answer to AIFMD, so the UK regulatory equivalent I suppose of what we've had in Europe for some time. The FCA links explicitly to both those pieces of regulation in the FRAME consultation, this is not something that's been kind of done in isolation. The FCA has linked clearly to those things. I think it also goes beyond those two pieces of regulation as well. If you read into the FCA's proposals around FRAME and some of the reporting requirements, you'll see other themes coming out. So, you'll see things around client categorisation, valuations which has been a hot topic for the regulator over the last year or so, and even things around value that products offer. So, when you stand back, you can see that the FCA is trying to get data that draws a number of these different initiatives together. As firms look at implementing FRAME, it's going to be important not to view it in isolation, but to think about this in the round.

Andrew: And I think that's probably true of so much of the regulatory environment at the moment. The regulator is doing so much at pace, and it does all link together, whether you're looking at retail stuff like CCIs and how that fits with costs and charges disclosures under MiFID provisions through to, as you say, the liquidity piece or the AIFM piece and how this links together.

Tom: Yes, and I think it's not every day is it that we get a new regulatory reporting regime.

Andrew: No, this is actually fundamentally different.

Tom: Absolutely, this is the FCA's opportunity to prove that they are going to be data led. I feel this is quite a significant step.

Andrew: Can we say, “filling its boots?” I mean there is quite a lot in this.

Tom: There is a lot.

Andrew: If you start with a blank sheet of paper, then why wouldn't you ask for a lot.

Tom: Yes, I think it might be something that we come on to later in the conversation, but we can't read an FCA publication or listen to an FCA speech without the word ‘proportionality’ coming out. And you see that in the consultation paper for FRAME. What the FCA has tried to do is be clear that the things that they're requesting are going to be used for a specific purpose. So yes, it might be larger, but I think they've been a pain to say, we are going to use this data to supervise firms and funds.

Dan: Super interesting. And I think what's insightful there is the point of not taking everything in isolation how this all comes together as one. And obviously you touched really well there Tom, on the UK element of that. Of course, there's also a more international scope as well. And Andrew, if we look specifically at Europe and the regime there, how do these proposed FRAME reforms align or differ from those European requirements? And is FRAME likely to have an impact on those European based firms as well?

Andrew: Yes, it's a great question and quite complicated because there's multiple European regimes and some of those are also under review as well. From a UK perspective, you're right, this applies to all funds and the big extension here is the application to UK UCITS funds. If I think about the European aspects to it, it's multi-dimensional then. This does apply to third country AFMs using the national private placement regime in the UK. It does apply to overseas funds, regime funds and 272 type funds as well. So, there's an extra territorial impact on those funds coming in. Equally, if you look at where Europe is going at the moment in terms of the Annex 4 revisions out of AIFMD2 that won't potentially apply into UCITS funds or will apply into UCITS funds, actually if you're a firm that's got UCITS exposure, which is now being captured in the UK, and you're looking at what the Annex 4 reporting might look like at a European level, there's some duplication there, but it's not the same. And actually, if you're for argument's sake, a small fund in the UK, so you're only caught by the essential reporting requirement, but actually you have other funds at a European level that are larger that are caught by the new Annex 4 piece, you might end up doing all of it really. I'm not sure if you have to do it anyway, why would you try and carve out bits of it? There's an interesting point around duplication, also potential divergence, and it's that import and export regulation. If we overlay the current political agenda as well, it does feel like we've had 10 years of perhaps doing stuff slightly differently from Europe. And actually, some of the mood music feels like maybe over the next 10 years, there needs to be greater alignment again. So, it's cyclic. We'll get back to somewhere eventually, but there's a lot of nuance there depending on your footprint, the funds, whether you're importing or exporting and so on as well.

Dan: Well, it's certainly called the Risk and Regulation Podcast, and we’ve certainly cover the regulation element there. So, let's turn to a few other aspects here. And Tom, amongst all of these changes, these proposals here, let's look at the practical data challenges itself. And all the data that the FCA is looking to gather here and get hold of. First, do firms have its hand at the moment? And second, what challenges are they likely to face when trying to get hold of it?

Tom: That's a big question Dan. I'll try and take it in chunks. Do firms have all the data? Probably yes, somewhere in the organisation. I honestly think that's only a small part of the of the question and of the answer. Some of the data, as Andrew has touched on already, will mirror what firms have had to report previously under the Annex 4 reporting in AIFMD. But there are also quite big changes here. There are new data fields, there are new products in scope, there are new thresholds, there are new frequencies of reporting. This is not just the same data that has always been used. So yes, it might be there somewhere, but the application and the use of that data is going to be different. Firms need to be doing more than simply looking at the new reporting template and just go down that list of data fields and go yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, we've got all these things somewhere in the organisation. There needs to be a rigorous approach to implementing this and to the data requirements. So, I've got a few points that spring to mind when thinking about the challenges that firms are going to have to grapple with. They're going to need to, first, identify which products are in scope of the requirements and which specific reporting requirements they need to adhere to. So, if you look at what the FCA is proposing, there's a table which sets out all these different reporting requirements and sections for different types of funds. The first challenge is identify which funds are in scope of which reporting.

Andrew: I'd also probably argue identifying which funds might be in scope of other reporting potentially too.

Tom: I think that's so important because you touched Andrew on that £500m threshold. There needs to be a process in place. So when you tip into that £500m, are you ready to stand up that reporting as and when you need to? There might also be a decision as to whether you want to apply the enhanced reporting to all your funds to save yourself the potential hassle and some regulatory risk that comes with divergent or different reporting requirements. Once you've determined which products are in scope of what data requirements, you then got to figure out what data is needed for each submission and where that data is going to be sourced from. This is going to be an interesting exercise for firms to go through. There's going to need to be a proper review of whether the data is held internally or whether it's held with third parties and how you're literally going to bring that data together for the purposes of this reporting and how quickly and how confidently can you can do that from different places.

I think there's something then finally, which is really important. How are you going to get comfortable that the data that you're producing is accurate and kind of in inverted commas, regulator ready. Like can you stand behind that data, the accuracy of it. What reviews are you going to put in place before your happy to press send and share it to share it with the regulator, which is a really important point, because we know from everything the FCA has put out there, they are going to use this data, they're going to scrutinise it, and they're going to use it to identify outliers as areas where they need to focus their supervisory attention. Getting that data right is going to be important. Even if the data might be there in some shape or form, there are lots of questions for firms to grapple with.

Dan: Thanks Tom. Super interesting takeaways there. And sounds like there's definitely a lot at stake for firms here in respect of how the FCA may be using the data in their day-to-day supervision, but also and we might touch on it later, the potential elements there of really how proportionate is this and what impact does that have on firms operationally to gather all of this? And on that point in particular, are there opportunities for firms to deploy advances in AI or technology to make that easier for them? And to what extent will firms have to undergo some significant data transformation to help meet the requirements that the FCA has now set out?

Tom: Thanks Dan. I think I'll probably just approach the question in reverse, if that's okay, and focus initially on the data transformation question and whether that's required. I don't think firms necessarily need to go through some major data transformation exercise in order to put an accurate regulatory report into the FCA. But those firms that are going to be most successful over the medium to long term are going to look at this more strategically. They are going to look at the data that they've currently got. They're going to look at the quality of their data and they're going to see this as part of a broader exercise. That requires a bit of upfront effort, so a bit of investment now, but that’s likely to pay significant dividends. We've already touched on the fact that the FCA is moving to being a data led regulator and it is going to be looking for insights and supervisory focus areas from the data it collects. Firms that aren't taking the same approach to their own data are going to be on the back foot if they're not doing the same thing. I think there's a strong incentive for firms to look at this as a data transformation exercise.

Picking up the point about AI and technology, that absolutely can be used and should be used to help firms comply with FRAME. But as ever, that's only going to be as good as the data that underpins this stuff. Getting your data right first and having confidence in that will then enable you to get the benefits that really come through AI and tech once you've done that. A good approach is to focus initially on your data and then to think about how tech can be used, not only to make the process of regulatory reporting more efficient, but also to think about how it might be used to ensure that your data is as accurate as possible before it goes into the regulator. There are a few different ways that firms could use AI and technology more broadly but get your data right first of all is the key point, I would say.

Andrew: Without dating myself here. I think back to AIFMD when it was implemented and the reporting there, firms found on the whole there was more friction around some of that data than they perhaps realised. Stuff didn't quite marry up in the way they hoped it would. So yes, that underlying data point is not something to be just glossed over, it is potentially quite a lot of work.

Tom. I completely agree. Data projects are never straightforward and never as simple as they might look at face value. Absolutely.

Dan: Andrew, we've alluded to it already, but from what we just heard from Tom there, there's clearly some challenges that firms might face in ensuring they're in a good position to provide the regulator with the data they need. But how does that marry up with the regulatory narrative coming from the FCA that FRAME will help streamline and simplify reporting? Is there a little bit more to unpack here? And is it really as simple as they say there?

Andrew: Yes, we have talked about it in part. This is very logical. If you're starting with a blank sheet of paper, what the FCA is talking about is what I'm sure firms will understand the regulator would want and firms would ideally want them themselves. I mean, it's useful. But we aren't starting from a blank sheet of paper. It depends whether you look at these proposals in aggregate or whether you look at it at an individual level. To be fair, even at an aggregate level, the additional cost for UCITS firms and funds is quite substantial. If you look at the CBA, it's quite a chunky number in there, to be honest with you. But then if you get to an individual level, it really does depend on the firm. So, if you're a a firm with a large number of UK UCITS or NURS ranges or you're a firm with a big NPPR footprint, it is going to be more of a challenge than perhaps other types of firms. It's logical, it will allow the regulator to be more efficient in the way it works and in the long run that will be better for the industry. But for some individual businesses, it's going to be a bit of a pain.

Dan: Awesome. Thank you very much for that there. And from the regulator's perspective, when they get that data, Tom's already mentioned about how it will help identify outliers and other uses it will have. Can you unpack that a little bit more? What will they be doing with that? How will they be looking to interact with firms once they've got that within their organisation?

Andrew: Again, I'll date myself, but you think back to the jokes around when EMIR was implemented and people just having rooms stuffed with forms that nobody ever looked at and templates and data that wasn't used. We're in a different world to that now. So, the data they're asking is very sensible. I also think some of the data will change over time. You know, private markets and liquidity risk might be something we're focused on at the moment. Going forward, it could be something completely different. I think the regulator will be keen to keep some fluidity in this so they can look for additional data should they ever need it. The FCA itself also has transformed a lot. So, it's invested in its ability to interrogate this data using AI, using a whole range of technology. So they will be using it more. And the approach the regulator has been taking around fixed firms versus floating firms. And it's keen to focus on those firms that are significant in terms of their impact on the market. If I look at the asset management space, there's some chunky firms that aren't in that fixed supervisory bucket but could have a big impact on the market. The regulator will use this to look at those kind of firms. As Tom says, the outliers point always is important. And that makes the regulator more efficient, which is great, and plays to that broader regulatory narrative. But if you're not in the middle, and you're a slightly different type of firm, it might feel a little bit more uncomfortable.

Dan: Yes, and just to build on what you said there, obviously recently, the back end of October, the FCA came out with their response to the Mills Review as well, utilising AI within supervision itself. So, as you say, data and the way the FCA will supervise will only get increasingly more important for firms as things develop. On the flipside Tom, you've mentioned that firms probably do have this data somewhere within the organisation, so it might not necessarily be to hand immediately and they might not be using it internally themselves. When they've got that data and they're having to provide it to the FCA, are there advantages for them to use it internally? How can they help bring about positive impacts as a firm with that to hand?

Tom: It's a great question and one that is really pertinent in this case. It's great when the regulator puts out some new regulation that is more than just a straight compliance exercise and this feels like it has the opportunity and the potential to be used much more broadly if firms seize that opportunity. What I'm really encouraging my clients to do when they're looking at the upcoming requirements is not to view this purely as a compliance exercise and a regulatory issue, think about what else might this data be used for you. You go to all this effort to source this data to make sure it's accurate, it's going off to the regulator, why wouldn't you use it internally to help you more strategically. Why wouldn't it or could it go to your product teams. Could they use some of that information to develop insights, to build their understanding of the products that they're offering, what makes them successful or not, how they're operating in practise. Could some of this data be used in governance forums? Could it go to committees? Could it go to boards to help those governance forums oversee the products that are being offered and to help them, for example, I don't know about the value that the products offer. The FCA has highlighted that as one of the areas it will look at when it's getting this data in. So, there are a couple of examples. Perhaps a final one, how might your compliance teams or other teams, but potentially compliance, look at that data before it goes off to the regulator or as it's going off to the regulator and say, what insights do we think the regulator is going to draw from this? As it goes out, you want to be on the front foot thinking about what story is this telling about our products, about our product range. And let's do something about it. Let's pre-empt any of those questions that that might come back from the regulator. That's just three potential use cases, I'm sure there are far more from this from this data. Finally, one point that comes out in the consultation paper, and it's tucked away a little bit. The FCA has said that it might use some of this data and publish it externally. So, it might anonymise it, it might collate it, and then it might publish it on its website, presumably. If that does happen, we're going to have a very rich set of data that firms can use themselves to compare themselves to their peers, to look at where the market has gone and is going, and to really inform strategic decision making. So, when you view it outside of a purely compliance exercise, there's an awful lot that can be that can be done with this data.

Andrew: Yes, that's really interesting. If you think to things like the value assessment type work and publications that went with that, and we're all pretty comfortable that no average consumer was going to read that kind of thing. But that data was out there, and firms now have the ability with technology to really harness that, look at it, compare themselves. You're right. And this is another great example of that benchmarking the firms can do.

Tom: Yes, hundred percent. And if you've gone to the effort to get that data in the first place, why wouldn't you be asking yourself what else you could use it for.

Dan: Certainly, lots of opportunities there for firms and some interesting points raised. Thank you very much, both there. Unfortunately, we're approaching time on what's been an insightful conversation. But before we finish, I think it'd be great if you could both give us some final thoughts. If you both had to highlight a couple of key priorities for firms right now in the context of the FRAME consultation and the wider conversation we've had, what would they be? Tom, do you want to kick us off?

Tom: Sure. My three priorities. The first one, get started today. As we touched on earlier, data transformation exercises are rarely straightforward, even if they look it on paper. There's a little way to go until we get final rules and implementation periods. Firms need to start thinking about this today, because that clock will start ticking very quickly. And these exercises are tricky. Secondly, don't view FRAME in isolation, I would say. Think about this in the context of the wider regulatory publications and developments that are out there and that the FCA has in mind. Try to link all these things together, that's going to mean that you can implement this in the most effective and efficient way. And thirdly, this is the point that we were just talking about a moment ago, and I would really encourage firms to do this, think strategically about how this data can be used beyond just regulatory reporting, I think there's a real opportunity for firms there.

Dan: Thanks Tom. Really useful. And Andrew, can you top those three?

Andrew: Well, I'm going to repeat Tom's final one because he's right. This genuinely has some commercial value and can be useful for firms. It's unusual in the regulatory environment I get to be positive about these things, but it really can be. The first one is engage a bit. It will be good for firms in some cases to go for it. My second two are much more regulatory and old school. The first one is, think about the regulatory consultation process that's going on here. We've got the prototyping going on already. There's likely to be changes in things like thresholds in my view, because alignment with the AFM rules would make sense, but therefore your reg affairs teams need to keep on top of that. And then the second of my regulatory points, which is my third point, is around the European piece. Like genuinely, it feels like some of the European policy development is also going to be particularly relevant in this case. And I suspect I'm going to be saying that more often over the next couple of years, but having the ability to think about this, not just from a domestic perspective, but thinking about it or the group-wide perspective is going to be important.

Dan: Brilliant. Thank you both very much for joining our discussion today. Lots of interesting takeaways. For me, it's interesting to see how the FCA's long mooted move to being a data led regulator is really playing out here and the impact that it will have both in supervision, but also the benefits that firms can reap from that internally as well is some super interesting points you guys have pulled out there.If you would like to find out more about regulatory developments in the AWM market, then please do get in touch. Tom and Andrew would love to hear from you. And if you enjoyed this episode, please do subscribe and consider leaving a rating or review as it helps other listeners to find us. Thank you for listening and we'll be back next month for another episode. Goodbye.

Follow us