Transcript: AI and the future of work in financial services

Peter Brown: Welcome to the latest podcast on a workforce transformed. We are living through a period of profound change, driven not least by AI and other technologies, with significant implications for the economy, society and the nature of work. There are clearly huge opportunities for productivity and growth, but also some really important questions about how work involves the skills we need and how prepared financial services That's why the Financial Services Skills Commission undertook a major piece of research supported by Lloyds Banking Group. See the city UK and the City of London Corporation. Drawing on input from organisations right across the financial services sector and to bring that research to life and, importantly, explore what it means in practice.

I am delighted to be joined by Claire Tunley and Sharon Doherty. Claire is the CEO of the Financial Services Skills Commission and has been right at the heart of the research, with a pretty unique view across the sector of how these changes are playing out. And Sharon is the chief people and places officer at Lloyds Banking Group, leading through many of these changes in practice inside one of the UK's largest financial institutions and employers. Welcome both. And Claire, Perhaps if I could start with you and if you could ground us on the report, what are the three things that people really should know? And is there anything that surprised you in the research?

Claire Tunley: Sure. The work really did a broad view of how technology is changing the sector. And although we looked at all sorts of technologies, AI was the key technology that came out most prominently. And I think the key takeaways are that the impact of the AI transformation shouldn't be underestimated. No role will be untouched in this, but the time scales for this change are unclear at the moment. Adoption is very enthusiastic, but it's very cautious to really trying to work out what the opportunities and the challenges of AI adoption transformation are.

The other thing we found is that work's being redesigned, not eliminated. It was very much a key part that we saw that a lot of disruption within roles in the tasks that people want to take in their roles are changing, but that work is changing with people. It's not reducing work overall, it's just changing the work. And the final key takeaway is, is that success very much depends on execution. And this really is a universal technology. Everyone has access to it. But to make the most of it, firms have to be really thinking through their workforce strategy, how they're going to adopt what and how we build people capable of using the technology. So it's a profound change for the sector, but it really does depend on how you build your people to make advantage of it.

Peter: And that's a beautiful segue into Sharon. Sharon, you are living this in practice, right, at Lloyds Banking Group. That's what the research is telling us. What's happening in in real life.

Sharon Doherty: Thank you. Pete, look, before we get going, I just wanted to say I reread the report last night, Claire, and was just really impressed, actually, with how thoughtful and comprehensive the report was. And we've been working together now for a few years. And what I've seen is consistently the FSC bringing together the industry, creating fantastic frameworks, bringing thoughtful, thought leadership that's really sort of challenged us all to think differently, work differently. And so I just want to say thank you to yourself and to to mark the chair there really, you know, galvanises the industry. I think we're actually probably nearly uniquely placed as an industry that has got that perspective.

We're, as you say, one of the biggest UK banks with 28 million customers. And I think if you look at financial services, you've got frontier organisations creating the models. You've got big tech that are trying to sort of figure out and their part to play in it. I think Pharma and Financial Services have got a front row seat on trying to figure out how we actually take this technology and make good use of it for our customers. We see it as a massive opportunity to create fantastic new propositions for our customers, and to just take out friction and make it easier for customers to be able to access more of financial services.

And so we started there with that North Star of growth and being able to do different things for customers, but recognising that senior people needed to go first. So learn lead by example and create a really constructive, positive and exciting narrative for a country, for customers and for our people. And that's really been the approach that we've taken and we're learning every day. Stay very humble, you know, even when you have successes, because everything changes really quickly. And we invest, invest, invest in our people on this subject.

Peter: Thank you. If I could explore a few things there, because I think looking at our research around the record levels of investment, particularly in AI, many CEOs see three people would sort of scratch their heads and say, I'm yet to see the return. Yet you described a really positive story there, I think, around how you focused it all around customer outcomes. And I know with Lloyds one of your aims is around helping Britains prosper. Love to hear how AI enabled you to connect more, deliver better services if you like, to your customers and communities that you wouldn't have been able to do without AI.

Sharon: So look, we love helping Britain prosper. It resonates as a as a big employer and organisation with a lot of customers in the country. And we take that really seriously. If we are a successful organisation and AI is helping us to do that, then that helps UK plc. When we've looked to build skills on AI, we're really blessed that of our 55-60,000 people, they're all across the UK and so we're able to train our workforce right around the country, which is putting future high paid skills into communities right around UK, not just in London. I think, you know, practically you see it working there.

And the example I love most is, you know, how do we get to a place of democratising wealth? So 10 to 15% of people in the UK can afford investment advice. And with AI, actually, you can completely change the economics of that. We have been working with the regulator to create what we call invest AI, and that that just starts to take something that only a few could do before and put it into the hands of many, so that even if you've only got 10 pounds a week, you can start making different choices in how you can invest your money for tomorrow. And if we didn't have AI, we just couldn't make the economics of it of it work. And I think there's lots of examples of that. When you go across the different parts of financial services

Peter: And Claire, on that different parts of financial services. What do you see across the sector? Is it Sharon describes, I think, a really positive story around how AI is being used to benefit customers and colleagues at Lloyds Banking Group. Is that consistent across the sector at the moment?

Claire: Yeah, it is definitely. Everyone's looking at this. It's not optional. It's you know, an imperative for every firm to look at it. But everyone's approaching in a slightly different way. And we definitely saw that across the research. You can see all sorts of opportunities. So a lot of the processes taking out some of the friction in the back office, whether that's helping customer service understand where the customer's challenges are and get them to the right conclusion or support, whether it's about underwriting propositions that actually can be generated much more quickly. You've got endless labour with AI, but then where do you put the human in the loop?

I think what we did find, which was not a surprise, but it was it was a good finding, was that there's everyone's on a different point in the journey. And some firms, particularly the smaller end, very much content, just watch and learn. And because there's an awful lot that still needs to be worked out, where those processes can be optimised, where there are frictions in the system, where there's still questions over and AI's outputs and how we question them. It's turn the workforce planning question on its head, because the traditional structure of bringing people in at an early career, you learn the ropes, you move up, it's shortening those timescales and that ability to do work, but it's also lengthening some of that. How do you how do you get that experience in the industry for the long term, when AI can help you shortcut some of your work? So it's raised an awful lot of questions that we're still looking to answer in the next phase of our research.

Peter: Well it does. And you both paint an optimistic and positive for you, which I totally understand and agree with. But I think cliche time, you know, the amount of times I hear "Oh yeah, we need to redesign work" and everyone talks about that. That was after the adoption wave. What do you see across sector in terms of this redesign of work? Are we just layering technology AI onto historical existing ways of working and organisational structures?

Claire: It's early days. That was a key takeaway for me from the research. We are absolutely in the foothills of this transformation. So there's a long way to go. And where the real hard work is being done is looking at a task-based level, the tasks that someone does in their day job actually, how much of those can be supported, eliminated, enhanced by AI and really getting down to that. That detail allows you then to figure out where you can apply the technology, but then also what's left and where you can then use someone's existing skills, experience expertise to add value in different places. That's hard work. That takes a long time to map that, and that takes a certain level of organisational sort of sophistication to do that. But we've got a number of firms that we're working with in our membership, and in some ways, you need to have the understanding before you can apply this.

There's a general level of AI expertise that people need to have in the workforce, but then it will vary depending on what work you're doing, what your job is, what your role is, what your outputs and your KPIs are. And that takes time to work through. And how do you build an agency to this? How do you change managers to manage agents and people? How do leaders need to lead to lead this transformation? How do you look at early careers? These are all questions that are sort of being thrown up in the air.

Peter: by 2035, I think it's 450,000 people within financial services in the UK will have left the sector through retirement, through moving to different sectors, through stopping working right out of a population of about 790,000. So more than half. And you talk about leadership skills and judgement and then the experience, you know, that's leaving the sector. At the same time, some research we recently released with the World Economic Forum specifically looked at the impact of AI on entry level jobs, which is right in the in the crosshairs. So how concerned, Sharon, should the sector be? And then a follow on, I'd love to hear how Lloyds is addressing that early recruitment onboarding challenge opportunity.

Sharon: So look, I have a view that partly financial services also need to be able to bring people in from other industries into it. And actually I can't remember the number, when we looked it was actually a small amount of people move into financial services. So I think there is a moving in and moving out dimension that would be really healthy for the industry. Given that, scale of retirement, it completely doubles down on the reason to bring young people in. I'm pleased that while some of the broader context on entry level roles shows a reduction in financial services, it's staying pretty consistent. We hire, about 500 graduates in apprentices a year because we recognise we have a part to play in society with young people, with the sort of million NEETs that we're all talking about right now.

So we can only employ a certain amount of people, but actually we can go broader. We're helping young people with a few days work experience. So, you know, how can we get them work ready. So how can we take the scale that we have and the insight that we have, and just small amount of work experience can suddenly make a an 18 year old as they walk through the door, understand how you turn up what you say. I think we've been underestimating young people for a long time, and I think if we all went back to our work experience, you know, our work experience and our graduate roles in our head, even 30 years ago, we were going, you know, is this what work is about? Well, I see it as actually an opportunity to start taking fantastic young people and and giving them the work that they should have been getting. All our experience shows that, you know, they run towards technology, whether they've done a tech degree or not. And so they are much more proficient on this technology, prepared to use it and try it. There's lots of opportunities here in financial services for us to help young people.

We've just released the Global Hopes and Fears survey, one of the largest surveys of workers around the world. And against the narrative around adoption of AI, I think 64% of workers say they're using AI on a daily basis in work. And of those, seven out of ten actually report being much more positive, much more empowered. And interestingly, they report greater levels of job security. Yet at the same time, there's been a significant decline in trust in leadership and management, the challenge for organisations to keep up and race that that skills, capacity and capability that's coming on.

Sharon: And energy! And all those fantastic things is why we just need more young people in our organisations.

Claire: But I think it's tricky to characterise it as just a thing that young people can do, because and you've got some really fast adopters at all parts of the workforce. There's a generalisation of the challenge at senior leadership level. Leaders are leading very different organisations, even to just a few years ago, and that requires learning and development. Lots of organisations are investing in that leadership and management development because you're no longer just leading financial institution. It's a tech institution, and this technology is everywhere. And you have to make very clear decisions that the workforce will need to trust you on. And that that comes back to the trust point.

I think if you're kind of mid-career, the reskilling and upskilling is really important. Those skills have to be relevant. Maintaining your capabilities and your relevance to work to the future is really important. That's a challenge for the individual, the organisation, to go on a journey together. There needs to be that collaboration. I agree with Sharon. I think there's huge potential. Speaking to leaders in the sector, those that have got the the kind of real foresight see this as a huge opportunity. I spoke to the CEO of a very big investment management firm. He said, I can see the opportunity of putting together a grad who can build models and use AI in ways that many of my workforce never would imagine. But if I put that individual together with someone who's been in the industry for 30 years, knows it backwards, what can they create together?

One thing that struck me through the research was the premium on experience, where individuals have really deep knowledge of the sector, the regulation, the processes, etc. and how things work when AI is coming up with things, being able to challenge and critique that and actually spot when it's slop and it's nonsense, that is really valuable. But like the CEO said, how do I get those two ends of the part to work together? I spoke to your CEO, Sharon, a few years ago, and he said, my biggest challenge is teaming, getting those different parts of the business to work together to create something new.

Peter: So on that leadership point, Sharon, you've held multiple very senior leadership roles across different sectors. With the pace of AI in particular and the challenge that brings to your workforce or designing work, how do you give your workforce confidence? Because at the same time you're unable to give them certainty, right? So how do you navigate that?

Sharon: Well, when have we ever been able to give workforces certainty? Not in the 30 years that I've been working. I think we underestimate our workforce and what they expect. I think people expect you to lead by example, do your own training, have a plan, engage and talk to them about the opportunities. If they want to have a long term career, then they have to really get hands on with this technology. So all employees of 12-15 months have had access to all the tools, training, and we see it as almost like software releases. So it's coming all the time, and their confidence grows with being hands on with their, you know, the phrase of you won't lose your job to AI, but you'll lose it to someone who's using it. I think people really get that now.

We can't guarantee people jobs for live, but we can increase their employability. People increasingly understand that and are excited about the opportunities of it. We are lucky we can make investments and so therefore people feel supercharged by this technology. We're very fortunate to be able to put all these tools in our people's hands.

Peter: Sounds like you have an environment there where you've got leaders who have been clear and transparent with the workforce, but also, you know, people talk about giving you workforce permission and that safety. That's what I'm inferring from the way you've described the environment that Lloyds, Sharon.

Sharon: Yeah, we look at it in three levels. We have big bets. There's our enterprise-wide bets, the big sort of game changing opportunities with customers. Then you'll have within divisions, you'll have, you know, initiatives that, individual executives are championing. And then you've almost got a movement across the organisation with operating at the three levels, so that at all levels, you've got an organisation that is experimenting, succeeding, failing, learning at a pace that has just given people confidence.

Claire: I think that was something in the research. We found numerous examples of that where firms had said, those people that are naturally inquisitive and pushing the boundaries of this, we're going to let them do it, because that's when the innovation is waiting for everyone to get managers to tell them how. Lots of firms have actually, like Pete said, give them permission and that's where you'll get the innovation.

Sharon: And we talk about being literate, fluent, native. So native are people that are redesigning workflows at the three levels. And it isn't all the natives are in tech, which I think is amazing. So you've got lawyers, HR people, finance people who are just really interested, and they are looking at their workflows at one of those three levels and going, actually, the agents or this technology can help me do things differently.

Peter: So Claire, look echoing Sharon, brilliant job. Convening all the organisations across financial services is such a positive and collaborative way. Phase one tick. You're now just kicking off phase two. What's that going to bring?

Claire: Well, no you're right. It's been...the first report is long and detailed. But I do revisit it a lot. We couldn't have done it without the support of PwC, of Lloyds Bank, The City UK and City of London Corporation. It is a collaboration. That's how the commission operates. But that doesn't mean we've got we've got all the answers. So phase two is very much around how we then build the talent we need, how we tackle some of these big questions, how we increase the amount of upskilling and reskilling that's going on, how we redesign those early career pathways. And who needs to do those things for the industry to do? What's for education training sector to do? What's for different government of all levels to do so. So that's coming. That's due in early 2027. So we are deep up to our elbows in in the field work now.

Now aside from the research we're doing there's another initiative which runs alongside it called the Financial Services Skills Compact. So this is something that we've developed with alongside the Treasury. And it's got the support of government. And it's a commitment that firms can make to effectively a to two key commitments. One is to upskill and reskill their staff in AI and other critical skills on a rolling three year period. So basically, everyone in the industry and everyone in their firms will get reskilled over a three year period. And then the second commitment is to maintain and grow those early career and those other routes into the sector, whether that be graduates, apprenticeships, career returners, etc.

It's a recognition that we can't solve some of these challenges individually as firms, it has to be collectively as a sector. So this is this is about moving forward as an industry, in recognition that talent moves, people get different jobs, but actually that talent does move around. And if we can upskill and reskill everybody and maintain those pathways in, then we're in a much stronger position for the future of the industry.

Peter: So, Sharon, if I could come to turn to you just as we close this section, now you're sitting down with a CEO another Chief People Officer, who is perhaps an organisation that's not as advanced as you are at Lloyds banking group. What's the one thing you'd tell them to focus on?

Sharon: Training their senior leaders, starting with themselves. Yeah, we started and we're blessed - Charlie is a technology director, really, as well as a fantastic CEO. So he loves the technology. And I think, you know, as a CEO, like, you've really got to get your feet wet on it. You've got to then make sure that your senior team are all over it. They understand the technology. They're thinking through the implications for their organisation. If your leaders get it, then they create the right clarity, the right plans. They mobilise their workforce, they reskill, they train, you know, they do all of the right things and it'll happen. So that would be the one piece of advice

Peter: It doesn't have to be tech led skills. What we’ve seen a huge spike in amongst our members, is adaptability and skills such as adaptability being really important because firms are saying we don't know where this is going to take us. We're on the journey, we don't quite know the destination, but we do know that we're going to have to change as we go. So being able to adapt and spot those opportunities and not be spooked by all these changes is really important.

Sharon: I think all of us. You know, when we ask what's what's stopping you? People say "time". And so I think, as you know, we will gain some efficiencies from from AI. I think we as organisations need to be thinking about what we put back. So we create time for people to be able to learn

Peter: and actually embed that learning in work workflow.

Claire: I agree 100%. You know something we keep a very close eye on. And actually the time that people have to learn, is to remain consistent. It hasn't dipped. It hasn't gone up.

Peter: Okay. On something completely different. Sharon, if I could start with you, is there something that you've maybe read, watched, listened to in the last couple of weeks, maybe when you've been having some holiday, that's really made you stop and think and maybe causing you to think I'll do something differently as a result.

Sharon: So OpenAI have just done some research that is looking at how AI will change the shape of functions. And I think, you know, all my life we've had, you know, finance, HR, legal, tech, da da da, and actually, they've done some nice thinking on, on actually how as things go much more end to end workflows. I think some, some of those functional, silos almost, I think are going to start to get challenged. I, I'm really excited about that. I think that's going to create massive opportunities for us to think differently about work and skills and the environments we create for our people. So I think, you know, that's worth going and having a look at.

Peter: Claire?

Claire: Yeah, thanks. I listen to podcasts as well normally when I'm out for a run and so I have a number that I've listened to, but the one in the last week that I listened to was an interview with Alexander...now I'm going to say Ceferin. I think I've pronounced that right. UEFA President? I found it a really interesting interview, aside from all the politics and Infantino and the FIFA discussions, it was a really interesting just understanding how in his role has to balance the interest of so many different players, the fans, the clubs, the different constituents across different football bodies around the world.

And it really sort of spoke to me. You know, my role is, you know, we've got a membership body of 50 organisations working with government, working with different sectors, different stakeholders. And I just found that quite that resonated with me. So although it's completely different context and football, isn't this a world I'm not familiar with some of those challenges. And that balancing was really interesting, and I've never heard someone deny so much that they wanted the top job at FIFA, but I actually think he does.

Peter: Claire and Sharon, thank you so much for your time today. It's been a pleasure to talk to you and to get your insights and learnings. Thank you very much indeed.

Contact us

Peter Brown

Peter Brown

Global Workforce Leader, PwC United Kingdom

Tel: +44 (0)7789 003712

Darren Ketteringham

Darren Ketteringham

Partner, Financial Services Leader, PwC United Kingdom

Tel: +44 (0)7841 563947

Follow us